I have always believed in doing good work. I appreciate people who take their responsibilities seriously, pay attention to details and want to get things right. There is nothing wrong with having high standards. In fact, I think every workplace needs people who care about the quality of what they do.
However, there is something I have observed in the workplace that I think is worth discussing: the difference between striving for excellence and being a perfectionist.
They may look similar from a distance, but they are not always the same thing.
I have come across people who are very good at what they do. They know their jobs, understand their responsibilities and have years of experience. Yet, when it comes to getting things done, they insist on doing everything the way they already know how to do it.
There is little room for another approach. Little interest in exploring a different method. Even when someone suggests another way of achieving the same result, the response can be resistance.
This is where I begin to question what we call perfectionism.
Is it really about getting the best result, or is it about getting the result only in the way we are comfortable with?
I believe there is a difference.
Excellence allows room for improvement. It recognises that there may be a better way to approach a task, solve a problem or manage a situation. A person who values excellence can learn from others, listen to suggestions and adjust when necessary. The goal is to get the work done well.
Perfectionism, in the sense I am describing, can become too attached to a particular method. The person knows one way to get something done and keeps returning to that method, even when the situation calls for a different approach.
The problem is not that the person wants to do a good job. The problem is when the desire to get everything right becomes an unwillingness to learn something new.
Experience does not automatically mean growth.
Someone can have ten years of experience and still be repeating the same one year of experience ten times. They may have become very familiar with a process without ever questioning whether there is a better way to handle it.
I think this is important in business management and people management.
A business needs people who can do more than follow familiar instructions. It needs people who can think, observe, make decisions and respond to situations that were not necessarily part of the original plan.
What happens when the usual process fails? What happens when the person responsible is unavailable? What happens when a customer raises an issue nobody anticipated? What happens when the road you planned to take is suddenly blocked?
You cannot always wait for someone to tell you what to do next.
You need people who can think in different directions. People who can improvise, use their initiative, find alternatives and make sensible decisions within their responsibilities.
I like people who can think in seven, eight or nine directions. People who can look at a situation from different angles and are willing to consider possibilities beyond what they already know.
Imagine someone drawing a straight line and deciding that it is the only route to the destination. The line is clear. The process is familiar. Everything is planned.
Then something changes. The road is blocked.
What happens next?
Does the person stand there insisting that the road must open because that was the route they planned? Or can they look around, consider another direction and find a way forward?
That ability to adjust matters.
It does not mean doing things anyhow. It does not mean abandoning standards or making careless decisions. It means understanding that the desired result may have more than one route.
There is also a place for mistakes in the learning process.
Nobody becomes experienced without learning. Some lessons come from doing things right. Others come from trying something, getting it wrong, reviewing what happened and finding a better way.
I am not advocating carelessness or repeated negligence. I am saying that people need room to learn, experiment responsibly and improve. A mistake that is examined and learned from can become valuable experience.
If people are so afraid of getting something wrong that they refuse to try another approach, how much room is there for growth?
A workplace should not become a place where everyone is afraid to suggest something different. It should be an environment where people can contribute ideas, learn from one another and improve the way things are done.
For me, excellence is not about being the person who knows everything or gets everything right the first time. It is about being willing to do the work well, recognise where improvement is needed and remain open to learning.
A person can be good at a job and still have more to learn. A person can have years of experience and still benefit from another person's perspective.
That should not be a threat to anyone.
I would rather work with someone who is willing to think, learn and adapt than someone who insists on doing everything perfectly in one familiar way.
Getting it right matters. Knowing how to move forward when things do not go as planned matters too.
And in a workplace, we need both.